← Previous · All Episodes
The Great Clubs No. 001: Muirfield — The Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers Episode 297

The Great Clubs No. 001: Muirfield — The Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers

· 06:06:04

|
The Great Club's Founding Partners
🏌️ Titleist, Presenting Partner — https://www.titleist.com
💼 Inglewood — https://www.ingw.com
⛳ Erin Hills — https://www.erinhills.com
👕 Holderness & Bourne — https://www.hbgolf.com
🎓 Western Golf Association & Evans Scholars Foundation — https://www.wgaesf.org


The Great Clubs is our new long-form series: one club, months of research, the most complete telling we can give. No. 001 is the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers. In 1744, twenty-two Edinburgh gentlemen asked their town council for a silver club, were told to write down the rules, and produced thirteen articles that still shape the game. Over the next three centuries, they were pushed off their ground twice, went broke, sold their clubhouse, took the Open Championship with them, and finally built Muirfield, a course critics first called "nothing but an old water meadow." This is the story of a once-small society of eighteenth-century Scottish gentlemen who became one of the world's most influential, turning golf from a recreational pastime into the institutional playbook almost all clubs follow today.

Host Matt Considine and co-host Dr. Kevin Moore ("The Professor") spend six-plus hours on how a group of friends who wanted golf, dinner, and claret accidentally invented the golf club as we know it, and what happened the day they finally owned the ground under their feet.

The conversation dives into:
  • Before the club: early stick-and-ball games, a fatal swing, Charles I at Leith, and the townspeople who shared the links
  • Leith: the Silver Club, the 13 Articles, and John Rattray, first Captain and Jacobite surgeon, whose life was very likely saved by a man he knew from golf
  • Musselburgh: debts, a sold clubhouse, the gutty ball, six Opens, and the decision to leave a town that had built itself around the championship
  • Muirfield: Old Tom Morris, the "old water meadow," Harry Colt's two loops, and the champions it crowned, from Hilton and Braid to Nicklaus to Buhai.
  • 2016–17: the vote on women members, the lost Open, and what a 280-year-old club decides it wants to be next
  • The playbook: key themes that enabled the club’s success and longevity and what every private club still borrows today.
Episode companion
📘 A full list of our sources and research, chapters by act, and our Founding Partners in one PDF: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1dOxlhYP5bQvzWIR-8yIgmgIkRGSHA3Yl/view

Get The Bag Drop by email
📬 New episodes, our takeaways and research photos, and your vote on the next Great Club: https://thebagdrop.fm/email

Join NewClub

The Bag Drop

Connect with Matt & The Professor
🎙️ Matt Considine — 🐦 X/Twitter: https://x.com/consequential85 | 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/consequence18/ | 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/matt-considine-103bb21/
📚 Dr. Kevin Moore ("The Professor") — 🐦 X/Twitter: https://x.com/kevcmoore | 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/kevcmoore | 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kevin-moore-177b30b3/
🗣️ Corrections, arguments, and the club you want next — 📧 thebagdrop@newclub.golf

Chapters
0:00:00 Cold open: a toast, and "now are we tracking?"
0:03:10 From the first rules to Muirfield: why this club
0:10:00 Act I, Leith: the 1632 Kelso account and golf's murky origins
0:30:19 Divots were roofs: who else used Leith Links
0:46:30 Tavern gatherings and the beginnings of a club
0:53:17 1744: the Silver Club and the first competition
1:03:08 The thirteen articles, rule by rule
1:28:35 Rattray, the 1745 rising and the friend who saved him
1:34:42 Claret, wagers and the bett book: clubbiness at Leith
2:05:40 Broke at Leith: the financial crisis
2:15:07 Act II, Musselburgh: recovery and the move east
2:31:38 The gutty ball changes who can afford golf
2:57:40 Prestwick, the first Open and Musselburgh's turn on the rota
3:18:16 Leaving Musselburgh, and taking the Open with them
3:26:49 Act III, Muirfield: the search for land
3:38:38 Old Tom Morris builds Muirfield in a hurry
3:47:08 1892: Harold Hilton and the first 72-hole Open
4:27:58 Harry Colt and Robert Maxwell redraw the course
4:52:17 The club first: secretaries, visitors and a hickory match after hours
5:16:00 Cotton, Player, Nicklaus and Trevino
5:28:48 Faldo's eighteen pars, Els in the storm, Mickelson's 66
5:51:06 2016–22: the vote, the lost Open and the Women's Open
6:13:43 The playbook: what makes Muirfield Muirfield
6:29:34 Thanks, sources and a dedication to Tim Miller

A note on this episode
The Professor and Matt are not members of, or involved with, the clubs we discuss. Everything here comes from our own independent research and is not an official record of any club.

What is NewClub?
A golf club without the real estate. One membership, a rotation of great courses, tee times, competitions, trips already on the calendar, and people who love the game the way you do. We play as visitors at the courses and clubs that host us, and those relationships are the heart of what we do. Learn more at https://www.newclub.golf

View episode transcript


Creators and Guests

Matt Considine
Host
Matt Considine
Founder of NewClub and self proclaimed 'feel player'. Matt’s junior golf career led him to the University of Akron where he met our co-host. During his junior year, Matt Studied abroad in Ireland and discovered golf societies. Subsequent trips to Scotland fed his passion for the history, ideals, and culture of accessible, affordable, and sustainable golf, a concept he would later bring to the U.S. with NewClub. Known for his interviewing style, quick wit, and compelling storytelling, Matt brings thoughtful, reflective conversations to The Bag Drop. His professional journey before NewClub included multiple leadership positions in growth-stage startups, where he managed teams responsible for more than $250 million in revenue. Matt actively gives back to the game as a Board Member of the First Tee of Akron and past chair of the Evans Scholar Foundation. Proudly based in his hometown of Akron, Ohio, Matt finds inspiration in family life with his wife, their three children, and their golf dog, Gypsy.
The Professor
Host
The Professor
Every golf sicko's favorite educator. Kevin is a thoughtful and deeply curious host. His studied, constructivist approach adds intellectual enrichment and balance to the show. As a professor of Math Education at the University of Georgia, Kevin's background in applied mathematics and cognitive psychology uniquely informs his insights on golf strategy and performance. Originally from Ohio, Kevin was a Division I collegiate golfer at the University of Akron, where his passion for understanding mathematical thinking began. After earning his doctorate from Arizona State University, he combined his analytical expertise with his love for golf by co-founding Golf Blueprint, an organization aimed at helping golfers optimize their games through data-driven strategies. Kevin enjoys balancing deep philosophical discussions with simple pleasures, such as indulging his sweet tooth, cheering on college football, and spending relaxed evenings with his friends, his wife, and their beloved dog, Nole.

Subscribe

Listen to The Bag Drop: Untold Stories in Golf using one of many popular podcasting apps or directories.

Apple Podcasts Spotify Overcast Pocket Casts Amazon Music YouTube
← Previous · All Episodes